Returns & Exchanges

Due to the perishable nature of our small-batch gourmet peanut butters, we are unable to accept physical returns of opened or unopened jars. If your order arrived damaged or incorrect, please reach out to our support team within 14 days of delivery for a full replacement or store credit.

Return Process

• 1.
  Inspect Your Shipment

  Upon arrival, carefully examine your jars for any signs of damage during transit or shipping errors.

• 2.
  Document the Issue

  Take clear photos of the shipping box, the shipping label, and the specific damage or incorrect items received.

• 3.
  Contact Support

  Email our team at support@nerdynuts.com with your order number and the photos you captured to initiate a claim.

• 4.
  Resolution Received

  Our team will review your request within 48 hours and issue a replacement shipment or a refund to your original payment method.